Hakone vs Beppu Onsen: Which Hot Spring Town Should You Visit?
We earn a commission when you book through our links on Viator (PID P00299531), at no extra cost to you. This is how we keep the site free. Learn more →
Hakone and Beppu both call themselves onsen towns, but they answer different questions. One is about fitting good baths into a trip that starts in Tokyo. The other is about hot water as the whole reason for going. I've bathed in both, and my advice below comes down to where your trip starts and what you want from the water.
I Did Both Hakone and Beppu. Here's What I'd Tell You First
Pick Hakone if you're starting from Tokyo with only a few days and want baths woven into a loop of railway, ropeway and lake. Pick Beppu if the hot water is the point: sand baths, steam vents, and a town that runs on geothermal heat. If your window out of Tokyo is short, leave Beppu for another trip.
Access is the practical difference. According to the Japan National Tourism Organization (JNTO), Hakone is Japan's most accessible onsen destination from Tokyo. JNTO's regional pages also note that Hakone Tozan Railway connects Odawara to Gora in the Hakone hills. Once you're up there, the loop keeps going: Lake Ashi pirate cruise is a signature Hakone experience. The Hakone Free Pass covers most transport in the region.
Beppu works on a different scale. The Japan Onsen official cultural tourism site backs this up: Beppu has Japan's largest volume of hot spring water output. In Hakone, the baths sit between sights. In Beppu, the steam is the sight, and it comes up through the pavement.
2 Hour Onsen Calligraphy Experience: The Experience
This workshop suits a Hakone itinerary because it gives you something to do between baths without adding another viewpoint. The listing describes a calligraphy session built around onsen water themes, with ink, brush and a finished piece to take home. Pass on it if you only have one day in Hakone and haven't bathed yet. The baths come first.

2 Hour Onsen Calligraphy Experience
From $60 · Price checked: Sep 2026
Best for: Culture-minded travelers who want a hands-on session that fits a Hakone itinerary
Not for: Anyone expecting a full bathing session; this is a studio workshop
A calligraphy workshop built around onsen water themes; ink, brush, and a takeaway piece, with bath visits planned separately.
Check availabilityExternal booking on Viator · pricing and cancellations handled by Viator
Where Hakone has the advantage
Hakone nearly won me over because of a wet Tuesday. In June 2023, I arrived in Hakone on a Tuesday morning in heavy June rain. The outdoor sights were pointless, since visibility from the ropeway was down to almost nothing. I went to a small sento near Gora station instead and found only three other people there. A sento is a neighbourhood public bathhouse, plain and practical, and this one had a tin roof. The rain on it was loud and steady, and the two hours I spent there beat any clear day ropeway ride.
What I took from that day: bad weather in Hakone is an excuse to spend more time in the baths, and the outdoor sights will still be there tomorrow. The seasonal pattern supports going in June, which is rainy season with fewer crowds. You can check the forecast with the Japan Meteorological Corporation and, if the ropeway is socked in, head straight for the water.
For a guided day in Hakone, the Hakone Full-Day Private Tour covers the ropeway, Owakudani, Hakone Shrine, the Open-Air Museum and a Lake Ashi cruise by public transport, with a foot bath stop along the way. It's a poor fit if bathing is the point of your trip, because the only soak is a foot bath. It makes more sense for a first visit where you want the main sights without planning the transport.

Hakone Full-Day Private Tour
From $253.66 · Price checked: Aug 2026
Best for: A first Hakone visit with a private guide and no transport planning
Not for: Travellers who want a ryokan stay or a full onsen bath, as the only soak is a foot bath
Private guided day around Hakone by public transport: ropeway, Owakudani, Hakone Shrine, the Open-Air Museum and a Lake Ashi cruise, with a foot bath stop.
Check availabilityExternal booking on Viator · pricing and cancellations handled by Viator
Beppu 7 Hells Private Tour: The Experience
The hells are for looking, not bathing, and you should plan the day with that in mind. According to the Japan Onsen cultural tourism site, Beppu's 'Hells of Beppu' are viewing-only hot springs, not for bathing. The private tour's selling point is pace. You go with a guide, without a group bus, and choose where to linger.

Beppu 7 Hells Private Tour
From $162.50 · Price checked: Nov 2, 2026
Best for: Travelers wanting the full hells experience without group bus crowds
Not for: Travelers who want to soak rather than just view the hells
Private guided tour of seven of Beppu's eight hells. No crowds, set your pace.
Check availabilityExternal booking on Viator · pricing and cancellations handled by Viator
The Kannawa district is where the steam turns practical. In March 2022, a local woman handed me a wire basket with two eggs and a sweet potato in it. She pointed at a steam vent in the pavement, hissing at boiling heat. I lowered the basket in, waited a few minutes, and pulled out perfectly cooked onsen tamago, though the sweet potato took far longer. She charged me a few coins and told me the vent has been used this way since the Edo period. Cooking times vary from vent to vent, so ask someone local before you drop your food in.
How to make the decision
Beppu decided it for me, buried up to my chin. If you want a bathing experience you can't copy on a day out from Tokyo, go to Beppu and book a sand bath. If being pinned under a heavy weight makes you panic, give the sand bath a miss and stick to the open-air pools.
On a summer afternoon in Beppu, I felt the hot volcanic sand press down on me shovel by shovel until only my face was free. Steam drifted up off the black grains beside my head. It was the oddest thing, being buried alive and oddly comfortable about it. The first minute felt claustrophobic. After that it was the most relaxed I have been in hot water, except I wasn't technically in water at all. If someone wants to try a sand bath, Beppu is where I'd send them.
The comparison I keep making is with home. On a weekday morning at an Arashiyama onsen in Kyoto, I watched mist lift off the river while the water held me still. Through the fence around the outdoor bath I could see the bamboo forest catching the early light. A temple bell sounded somewhere in the distance and nobody else made a sound. That quiet, contemplative kind of bath is closer to what Hakone offers on a good morning. I cover that pairing in my Hakone vs Kyoto comparison. Beppu is louder, steamier and more physical.
Evenings matter too. According to JNTO, Beppu is known for late-night bathing culture compared to other onsen towns. If you're a night person, that suits you. If you want to be in bed right after dinner, Hakone's ryokan rhythm will feel more natural.
Beppu Private Tour - Onsen Experience in nature: Where It Fits
This tour covers the part of Beppu that the hells don't: bathing outdoors in the countryside. The listing describes a private, customizable tour focused on nature-side onsen, in a small group. It suits travelers who want Beppu's water without bus crowds and without working out rural access on their own.

Beppu Private Tour - Onsen Experience in nature
From $122.01 · Price checked: Aug 2026
Best for: Travelers wanting a private Beppu experience without bus crowds
Not for: Budget travelers happy with a shared bus tour instead of private guiding
Private Beppu tour focused on nature-side onsen. Small group, customizable.
Check availabilityExternal booking on Viator · pricing and cancellations handled by Viator
You can find more Beppu planning on my Beppu guide and more on the mountain side in the Hakone guide.
Before you visit
Most of what I wish I'd known is about preparation, not the choice of town.
Etiquette first, because it isn't optional. The JNTO onsen etiquette guide sets out the basics. Wash thoroughly at the washing station before you get in. Bathe naked, because swimwear doesn't belong in an onsen. Keep the small towel (tenugui) out of the water, resting on your head or on the edge. Photos inside the bathing area are off limits.
Tattoos need a direct question. Policies differ from one facility to the next, and some ryokan with private baths still ask for covering in shared dining areas. Email or call the ryokan or bathhouse before you book.
Reserve a private bath (kashikiri buro) when you book the room, not at check-in, because weekend slots go early. Confirm whether a ryokan's rotemburo is private or shared before you pay.
Look after your body too. Keep each soak short, drink water before and after, and get out at once if you feel dizzy or nauseous.
Explore More
Related comparisons and guides:
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I combine the Beppu hells with a proper bath on the same day?
Yes, and I'd plan it that way. Book a sand bath or a public bath for the afternoon so the day includes time in the water as well as time watching it.
Is Hakone worth it as a day trip from Tokyo?
A day trip works if you accept that you'll only see part of it. I'd still stay one night so the evening bath doesn't turn into a race for the last train.
What should I pack for either town?
Pack cash, a handful of 100 yen coins for the lockers, and your own tenugui, because rental sets don't always include the small towel. In winter, a warm hat makes the walk between indoor and outdoor baths easier.
Which town is better in winter?
Beppu is warmer year-round, and Hakone occasionally gets snow, which can make its outdoor baths memorable if you're lucky. Leave Hakone out of your autumn foliage plans unless you can book four or more weeks ahead, because it gets especially crowded then.
How do I book a ryokan whose website is only in Japanese?
Email the ryokan directly in English with your dates and questions about bath access. Ask about tattoo policy in the same message, so you only need one exchange.
Written from Kyoto, Japan.